DISQUS

RockClimberGirl.com: Gear I'm reviewing right now...

  • paul · 5 months ago
    love the skirt ( go with a red one, it will look...daring on you). On the other hand, $80 for a skirt?
  • theclimbergirl · 5 months ago
    No, I totally know. I'm on an incredibly tight budget myself, so sometimes it takes a good, firm *gulp* for me to recommend an Arc'teryx piece, or whatever other quality brand I'm talking about. I scan sale racks for Ibex pieces (and find them at good retailers sometimes). It also helps that "affordable" brands just don't fit me... I remember the last time I tried on clothes at Old Navy and almost wound up in tears. I'm willing to pay a bit more for clothes that fit me well and that perform whether I'm mountain biking (the Rue skirt does, by the way), climbing, working or networking.
  • Jen · 5 months ago
    I love Ibex/ Merino wool gear, it's brilliant for outdoor gear, it doesn't take on smells like synthetics do. Plus, the base layers keep me super warm in the snow.
    What a winner.
    Thanks for the reviews Sara, I've been toying with the idea of replacing my MSR with a jetboil .
  • theclimbergirl · 5 months ago
    I know folks who have both, and I haven't heard a super objective reason for one over the other. Hopefully someone will chime in on here... I'll see if I can find you some input!
  • theclimbergirl · 5 months ago
    PS, I second the wool endorsement (or, third it?) ... I just didn't want to repeat my whole review here... I find merino to climate-adjust better than other fabrics (they keep me cool when it's hot, and hot when it's cool) and you're right about the smell. I'm trying to talk all my dude climbing partners into merino baselayers to save *my* nose.
  • Katie · 5 months ago
    Hi Jen and Sara! I've had the MSR Whisperlite stove for 5 years now, and I absolutely love it. I've never had to take it apart or mess with it, and discovered that it'll clean the fuel line itself if I shake it. It's so unbelievably easy to use. I had a bit of trouble lighting it when it got completely soaked, but other than that, I've never had trouble with it. It can be a bit annoying to search for a flat surface to put it on, but I've never really had difficulty.

    I've never considered a Jetboil, although I've seen them being used, because of the fact that you have to replace the fuel cannisters and throw the empty ones away. That's an absolute deal breaker for me, and the primary reason I'd never use one. Sara, can you recycle them or reuse them at all?
  • Katie · 5 months ago
    ....and I just saw you can recycle the cannisters, shame on me for not reading your full review! I guess I'm still wary of the cannisters, even if you can recycle them, it still uses energy to produce and break them down. Plus, I'm not fully convinced Philly actually recycles the stuff I put on the curb. Do you find you can adjust the cooking temperature well with the Jetboil? That's another thing about the Whisperlite that can be a bit annoying - the stove is either on or off, there's no in between!
  • theclimbergirl · 5 months ago
    I had the same hesitation. Here's how I try to mitigate my impact by using canisters...

    I buy the biggest fuel canister I can, so that I'm recycling less overall material (compared to buying small cans). To recycle, you just need to puncture the empty container and flatten it (there's a nice display in Neptune Mountaineering in Boulder, CO too, that I wish I'd snapped a photo of!). I'm 100% sure that the Jetboil is more fuel efficient than I am with a liquid fuel stove... there's no spillage, overflow, etc. And, because of the Jetboil's design, it heats more efficiently than the liquid fuel backpacking stove I tried (although, my climbing partner's Coleman is nearly as fast -- it just takes a "touch" that I can't seem to develop consistently to get the thing to light). For me, since I'm incompetent (and apparently, unteachable) with liquid fuel stoves, I would rather use the stove that lights easily without fuss, than the stove that lights with several tries, wasted fuel, and a bunch of drama (if at all).

    On temp adjustment... I've used my jetboil mostly to boil, and to simmer... I haven't tried to really fine tune the temperature but it does well between a simmer and a boil. I keep meaning to try scrambling eggs in it, so will let you know if I do that experiment... :)
  • Jen · 5 months ago
    Katie, I know exactly what you mean with the temperature on the Whisperlite (just looked on the MSR website and realised that's the model I have too). It's either hot or very hot; which is great when you want some water to get to the boil quickly, but not so great when you're trying to cook something a little bit slower.
    I've found one of the best tricks to get the Whisperlite burning clean and quick is to burn some broken up firelighters by the fuel pipe on the top level (does that make sense), when it's practically burnt out just let the valve open a bit and it goes straight away. Ok, it does mean you have a bit of faffing around to begin with, but it also means that it stays relatively soot free.
  • Explore It! · 5 months ago
    If you're looking to replace your MSR with a Jetboil, I suggest waiting until Fall when the Flash comes out. It includes a thermochromatic window thingy that changes color according to temperature (Hypercolor shirts anyone?).
  • Steve Schultz · 5 months ago
    Hi guys, this is Steve from Pemba Serves. We represent Jetboil in the Midwest and I figured I'd chime in here as well. Obviously I've got a bit of bias but I'll try to add to the comments already here.

    There are a couple things that put Jetboil into a different category from other stoves. The main realization for many people is that we don't just make a water boiler, we make a truly efficient Cooking System. Most people start off with the PCS and add on accessories as they go. Going from the 1-2 person system to the 3-6 person system takes about one minute and allows you to cater to different sized groups. An added plus is that everything will always fit into either the PCS or the GCS! My personal favorite is the Spatula that stows underneath the Frying Pan!

    I also want to confirm a couple things about canisters. Yes, they are recyclable! All you need to do is use them until they are basically out of fuel and then puncture them. At that point they are no different than a soup can! The other upside with canisters is that they are cleaner and easier to use. There isn't any need to prime the stove or spill any excess fuel. Just click the igniter and go! Also, because of the added efficiency of the FluxRing your canisters will use less fuel per boil and will, in turn, last much longer than you'd think.

    For what it's worth, my cooking generally comes down to heating up oatmeal and coffee in the morning, soup and crackers for lunch and maybe some chili or pasta at night. I've also done eggs and pancakes with the Frypan accessory, which was particularly fun. The PCS is small enough to fit into a crashpad easily enough so we end up taking it on daytrips almost the entire fall season.

    I've been lucky enough to use an early version of the Flash and the heat indicators and see through lid are a nice bonus if you want to wait until October 1st.

    I hope that clears some stuff up a little! Feel free to ask questions too! I'm happy to help.
  • Ian Ryerson · 5 months ago
    I am from Alaska and that is where most of my outdoor adventures have been. I switched from MSR stove to JetBoil and I don't regret it. Most of my meals here Mountain House while backpacking, or oatmeal. So with all I really needed was boiling water, it was the way to go. And the fuel last a long time!

    @ianryerson
  • Lindsey · 5 months ago
    Does anyone else just LOVE reading Sara's reviews? I wanna buy EVERYTHING she gives a good review to! Keep up the good work and good advice!!!
  • theclimbergirl · 5 months ago
    Can I quote you on that? Holy cow, best comment ever. :) I'm going to file that one away for the days when I get not so nice mail...
  • Greg · 5 months ago
    Hey, I used to have to tape my knees too. Now that I'm more active again I've been looking for some tape, 'cause my knees hurt! I'm gonna give a go on your KT and let you know how it works for my Pat-Fem problems. You forgot one downside to McConnell tape, by the way: we guys mush shave our legs a little. So sexy.

    Cheers!
  • Mark · 5 months ago
    Thanks for the info on the KT Tape. I go through sports tape in Karate and Climbing, and have wondered how good this stuff is. Big Thanks.